The Smiths on MusicBrainz

Go to page :   Previous  1, 2

Reply to topic
 
Author Message

Miblo ®

Gender: Unknown

Longevity: 8 years 3 months

Posts: 17

Location: Hazel Grove, Manchester

Post 02-Aug-2009 19:38

[Quote]

Having listened to it, my vote goes to "Rubber Ring / What She Said / Rubber Ring". This seems to be the best title, which abides by MBz's style guide. I'll start using this as the title for future additions, and also edit the ones we've already done, if that's okay. We can vote on edits in MBz anyway, so if there's a better solution my edits can be voted down, and the better one used.
[Profile] [PM]

XAVeRY

Gender: Unknown

Longevity: 9 years 3 months

Posts: 160

Location: Wroclaw

Post 04-Aug-2009 19:39 (after 2 days)

[Quote]

1983
1983-02-04: Hacienda, Manchester, UK (ripped from the DVD) (MBz)
1983-02-04: The Butterfly Collector: Hacienda, Manchester, UK (MBz)
1983-05-21: Camden Electric Ballroom, London, UK (MBz)
1983-06-03: Reel Around the Fountain: Fighting Cocks, Birmingham, UK (TODO - still trying to download this one...short on seeders, unfortunately)
1983-06-04: Brixton Ace, London, UK (MBz)
1983-06-29: Brixton Ace, London, UK (MBz)
1983-07-01: Midnight Express Club, Bournemouth, UK (MBz)
1983-07-06: Hacienda, Manchester, UK (MBz)
1983-07-07: Wonderful Woman: The Rock Garden, London, UK (TODO - downloading...)
1983-08-07: Lyceum, London, UK (MBz])
1983-08-09: Camden Dingwalls, London, UK (MBz)
1983-08-11: Warehouse, Leeds, UK (MBz)
1983-08-19: Gala Ballroom, Norwich, UK (MBz)
1983-08-30: Camden Dingwalls, London, UK (MBz)
1983-09-15: The Venue, Victoria, London, UK (MBz)
1983-09-25: Lyceum Ballroom, London, UK (MBz)
1983-09-30: University Of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK (MBz)
1983-10-05: I.C.A., London, UK (MBz)
1983-10-21: North East London Polytechnic, London, UK (MBz)
1983-10-22: Liverpool Polytechnic, Liverpool, UK (MBz)
1983-10-28: Mandela Hall, King's College, London, UK (MBz)
1983-11-16: Leicester Polytechnic, Leicester, UK (MBz)
1983-11-17: Incredibly Charming : London, Westfield College, UK (MBz)
1983-11-18: Edge Hill College, Ormskirk, Liverpool, UK (MBz)
1983-11-24: Hacienda, Manchester, UK (Steve's recording) (MBz)
1983-11-24: Hacienda, Manchester, UK (ripped from the DVD) (MBz)
1983-12-07: Assembly Rooms, Derby, UK (TODO - downloading...)
1983-12-19: Electric Ballroom, London, UK (MBz)
Sorry about the delay...the new Harry Potter book I got (the last one) got me a little preoccupied, and then, well, I drank one, it became four, and when I fell on the floor, I drank more... ;)
Miblo, do you really think that adding all the recordings of one show is necessary? In my opinion there's no need to focus on the old - mostly inferior to the new - versions.


Last edited by XAVeRY on 2009-08-09 23:56; edited 3 times in total
[Profile] [PM]

Miblo ®

Gender: Unknown

Longevity: 8 years 3 months

Posts: 17

Location: Hazel Grove, Manchester

Post 04-Aug-2009 20:35 (after 56 minutes)

[Quote]

I come in, smiling with gratitude, and say, 'I dunno, what do you reckon? I thought I'd try and do them all for completion purposes, but I see what you mean about the inferior ones being redundant. Do you think the ideal solution would be to have one recording, the best, for each date, and leave the rest to rot in hell? I may be happy to go along with that, but if someone is to download a particular recording - one of the inferior ones - wanting to use Picard to tag it,their files would end up being tagged with the information of only the best recording from that date, not the one they have. Shall we try and sort out examples of this sort of thing?
'Also, just watch out for the naming conventions, XAVeRY: colons shouldn't be preceded with a space, and I don't think the titles of named bootlegs should be surrounded with anything, besides being followed by a colon. But I think we're working our way through this little project quite efficiently, XAVeRY!'
With this I slam you a huge high-five, and slink into the shadows, marvelling at this ability of linking to web-pages with speech.
[Profile] [PM]
Display posts:    
Reply to topic

Current time is: 23-Aug 06:26

All times are UTC ± 0



You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum